King v Burwell is a total win for the ACA
June 25, 2015 Leave a comment
Chief Justice Roberts saved the ACA again, this time with a 6-3 ruling (Kennedy also joined the liberals) that says that tax credits can flow to persons in states that did not set up their own exchange, but who buy private coverage via healthcare.gov.
The case does not depend upon the so-called Chevron doctrine (where the executive branch of the govt is granted discretion when there is ambiguity in how to read a law). Instead, the majority says that because tax credits (and therefore the ability of people to afford health insurance) is such a fundamental part of the law, that the plainest reading of a narrow section of the law couldn’t be read to mean that tax credits are not not available in all states, regardless of the type of exchange through which they get coverage.
This is a complete victory for the Obama Adminstration. A reporter just asked me “what does the North Carolina General Assembly need to do now?” Answer: they can keep doing what they have been doing on health care for quite a while: nothing.
I hope that they will not continue to do this, and that our state will work out a way to put together a reform of our Medicaid program (that I am in favor of), as well as a means of expanding insurance coverage (that I am also in favor of). Here is a concrete idea for how to do this that I put forth in January, 2014.
There have been some statements that they were holding back due to the uncertainty caused by the looming King v Burwell case. There is no longer any uncertainty on that front.